Neocon Blog
The post for 7/27/06 is entitled The UN is Not Blameless. The subject is the UN's role in Lebanon. I assume the post was prompted by the controversy over the bombing of an UN observer post by the Israelis.
Here is a comment I submitted in response to the post:
I have a few problems you post. If the observer position you have pictured is the same one that the Israelis bombed then I would say that the UN forces made a fatal mistake in hanging around once the shooting started. But that would be a failure to take adequate force protection measures on the part of the local UN leadership.
You on the other hand seem to be blaming the victim. The UN forces are after all, observers. The UN itself hasn't actually enforced anything since the Korean War. You didn't offer any evidence that they were cooperating or aiding Hezbollah. And since they were tasked to observe, it probably made sense so cohabitate in order to observe Hezbollah. Given that UN observers probably have limited force protection capability it probably made more sense to colocate than not. It doesn't necessarily mean the UN force were co-opted.
I am also surprised to find a Neo-con that expects the UN to actually implement a resolution.
So I am not buying your argument for the partial justification for Israel targeting the UN post. On the other hand it is going to be a long war and this incident will be a minor atrocity when all is said and done.
On the other hand I think the naiveté and incompetence displayed by the Neocons/Bush Administration in pursuit of their Middle East agenda are to blame for the emboldenment of Hezbollah's supporters Syria and Iran. I find the analysis that Iran's position has been strengthened by the removal of Saddam very credible. I am afraid that the Neocons have fumbled the opening kickoff deep in their own territory.
The unfortunate reality of this sports analogy is that we have 130,000 U.S troops in a country with a Shiite majority. That country is barely in control by anyone. That Shiite majority cannot be happy with how the Shiite civilians of Lebanon are being treated by the Israelis.
I just hope the Green Zone doesn't join Diem Biem Phu and the Kyber Pass(1st Afgan War) in the list of military disasters